FundMyClub vs Givebutter
Givebutter’s pricing page says nonprofits pay no platform or processing fees when donors leave tips (the “Givebutter Guarantee”); with tips off it charges a 3% platform fee plus 2.9% + $0.30 per card gift. FundMyClub costs more per gift (10% + 5%), and in return supporters get team merch and every player gets their own link to the team goal.
Givebutter is a fundraising platform and donor database for nonprofits. FundMyClub is built for teams and clubs that want a page, player links and logo merch without managing a donor database.
Side by side
- Fee
FundMyClub
10% platform + 5% processing per gift
Givebutter
Tips on: 0% platform, processing covered by the Givebutter Guarantee. Tips off: 3% platform + 2.9% + $0.30 per card (1.9% + $0.30 ACH)
- What a team keeps from a $50 cash gift
FundMyClub
$42.50 of a $50 cash gift
Givebutter
$50.00 with tips on (Givebutter Guarantee, for nonprofits); $46.75 with tips off
- Merch
FundMyClub
Logo merch printed and shipped to each supporter who gives at a merch level
Givebutter
No merch reward listed on their pricing page
- Built for
FundMyClub
Teams, clubs, boosters, bands, PTAs
Givebutter
Nonprofits
Givebutter facts are from its own public pages, checked November 2, 2026. Cash gifts; on merch gifts, the cost of the item also comes out on FundMyClub.
Where Givebutter is the better pick
- Lower cost per donation, especially with tips on.
- A free donor CRM, auctions and other nonprofit tools.
Where FundMyClub is the better pick
- Supporters get merch with your logo, printed and shipped to them.
- No donor tip ask added to your supporters’ checkout.
- Built only for teams and clubs, set up in about two minutes.
Free to start. Set up in about two minutes.